Socratic Seminar

1

The point that was done during the seminar was more about the way to rid yourself out of the conflict. The thing we learned most is how to admit that you are wrong and how to say sorry. What helped to move the dialogue forward is the way we related the subject to other that are historic or that are done right now. We related them to our conversation either related to political or economical projects. At a point there were different ideas but no true debate was done because no one actually contradicted what someone had said. It was just that we got so into a subject that drove us out of the subject. Not very much domination but there were people who talked more than others and there are people who didn't talk at all. The evidence that people were involved in the conversation was more because they participated and always had an idea to share. The understanding of the question has been clarified to me because i made relationships between them and historical events that i knew and explored the ways it is similar and the way they are different. I don't really want to change any ideas that i had in the seminar so I'm staying with it. The best part of the seminar was when we go together to form the ideas. The worst part was when some people were drooling around and didn't say anything, and they had their own conversations. Though i don't really want to change anything in the seminar so i think it was good enough.


Massachusetts Senate poll loss threatens Obama's agenda

2
Tuesday 19 of January 2010, the republican Scott Brown has won and immense victory in the US senate seat in the state of Massachusetts left by the Senator Edward Kennedy who died. This is a problem that stands against President Obama's healthcare program who which is now doubtful of being. This will make the president's job even harder to pass the bill and now the most domestic policy is against him for his first year as a leader of the United States.

Positives and Negatives of the Reconstruction

0

In the map for the end of reconstruction it clearly shows that the popular votes were won by the Democrat Samuel J. Tilden but subsides a problem is that the electoral votes were won by the Republican Rutherford B. Hayes. This was a failure of the reconstruction because the states' government did not put in a law that is of which of the electoral votes or popular votes would be counted as the winners. There was also a failure in the states of Louisiana, Florida, South Carolina and Oregon because the votes were a shared because in the states existed both the democratic and republican parties. There is also a failure such as the Klan that which consisted of ancient confederates that would go and kill the republicans, black people and other people that may not agree with them. The poverty in the south still didn't change because there was a large portion of freed men and white men that remained poor and in the situation as before. The south's industrialization wasn't very successful for that purpose. There is also the fact that people still didn't think of black African Americans as the same as them but they thought of them as an inferior race.


The successes were that first of all the south and north got back together even if there was still enough tension between them. At the end there was the compromise of 1877 when the southern democrats agreed to give Hayes the presidency but in exchange he should remove the southern troops still present in the southern states. It also marked the end of the reconstruction. The southerners were free because the federal troops were gone and African American didn't risk anything because the thirteenth amendment has already gave them their freedom. Both Southerners and African Americans are winners and it is also important because they would be more free in the economic side.This was a great success because both parties were winners. There was also the come back of the southern economy and the increase and extension of an already present economy in the north. There was the Enforcement Act of 1870 which banned terror, force, bribery or other offensive actions to enforce the law. It was more pointed towards the KKK which was the most offensive thing right than. It was interesting that this law was made and I agree with it because it prevented from further murders and horrors present in that time of crisis. It also helped people air and not be scared. There were also the new amendments added to the constitution for further civil rights. This was a success but than later in history it wasn't the case and the difference between the whites and African Americans were different. That brought to them the civil rights act of 1964. Also there was success with the project of helping the freemen and their family to find new homes, jobs and reconstruct their lives in education. It is very important because after the war the freedmen were poor without any place to live and nothing to live on. The government like many of the present days governments helped them with their lives. Last but not least the southern states grew in their economy but also the education was enhanced to a system of mandatory education level which is very important because it change the education of the south and schools in the south that were basically based on military.

In the map for the end of reconstruction it clearly shows that the popular votes were won by the Democrat Samuel J. Tilden but subsides a problem is that the electoral votes were won by the Republican Rutherford B. Hayes. This was a failure of the reconstruction because the states' government did not put in a law that is of which of the electoral votes or popular votes would be counted as the winners. There was also a failure in the states of Louisiana, Florida, South Carolina and Oregon because the votes were a shared because in the states existed both the democratic and republican parties. There is also a failure such as the Klan that which consisted of ancient confederates that would go and kill the republicans, black people and other people that may not agree with them. The poverty in the south still didn't change because there was a large portion of freed men and white men that remained poor and in the situation as before. The south's industrialization wasn't very successful for that purpose. There is also the fact that people still didn't think of black African Americans as the same as them but they thought of them as an inferior race.

The successes were that first of all the south and north got back together even if there was still enough tension between them. At the end there was the compromise of 1877 when the southern democrats agreed to give Hayes the presidency but in exchange he should remove the southern troops still present in the southern states. It also marked the end of the reconstruction. The southerners were free because the federal troops were gone and African American didn't risk anything because the thirteenth amendment has already gave them their freedom. Both Southerners and African Americans are winners and it is also important because they would be more free in the economic side.This was a great success because both parties were winners. There was also the come back of the southern economy and the increase and extension of an already present economy in the north. There was the Enforcement Act of 1870 which banned terror, force, bribery or other offensive actions to enforce the law. It was more pointed towards the KKK which was the most offensive thing right than. It was interesting that this law was made and I agree with it because it prevented from further murders and horrors present in that time of crisis. It also helped people air and not be scared. There were also the new amendments added to the constitution for further civil rights. This was a success but than later in history it wasn't the case and the difference between the whites and African Americans were different. That brought to them the civil rights act of 1964. Also there was success with the project of helping the freemen and their family to find new homes, jobs and reconstruct their lives in education. It is very important because after the war the freedmen were poor without any place to live and nothing to live on. The government like many of the present days governments helped them with their lives. Last but not least the southern states grew in their economy but also the education was enhanced to a system of mandatory education level which is very important because it change the education of the south and schools in the south that were basically based on military.


Reconstruction

0


Johnson's Reconstruction Plan:

Andrew Johnson took office in Aril 1865 and congress was in recess until December. During the eight months Johnson made a plan of reconstruction that was much similar to the on of Abraham Lincoln. His plan was known as the Presidential reconstruction, it included certain laws:

It pardoned southerners who swore allegiance to the Union.

It permitted each state to hold a constitutional convention (without Lincoln's 10 percent allegiance requirement.)

States were required to void secession, abolish slavery, and repudiate the Confederate debt.

States could then hold elections and rejoin Union

The presidential Reconstruction reflected the spirit of Lincoln's Ten Precent Plan was more generous to the south.

Amendment 14 &15

Southern defiance of reconstruction enraged northern Republican in Congress who blamed President Johnson for southern Democrat's return to power. They were determined to bypass Johnson and put and end to his reconstruction plan, congress used one of it's greatest tools: the power to amend the Constitution. Congress overrode the president's veto. Then it took further action. Concerned that courts might strike down the Civil Right's act congress decided to build equal rights into the Constitution. In June 1866, Congress passed out the fourteenth amendment. It Stated that:

"All persons born or naturalized in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.”

Afterwards across the south, meanwhile, freedmen were beginning to demand the rights of citizenship: to vote, to hold public office, to serve on juries, and to testify in court. In a letter to the Tennessee constitutional in convention, Nashville freedmen eloquently presented the case for black voting rights. They had the fifteenth amendment, which states:

“The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude. The Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.”

Radical Reconstruction

The congressional republican who had drafted the fourteenth amendment consisted of two groups. One group was radical Republicans.


Radical weren’t much in number but they were increasing in influence, but most republicans though thought of themselves as moderates. A moderate is someone who supports the mainstream views of the party, not the more extreme position of it.

The moderates and Radicals opposed Johnson’s Reconstruction policies, opposed the spread of the black code, and favored the expansion of the Republican Party in the south. Moderate were less excited over the Radicals’ goals and giving the African American their civil rights. The Radical inequality was still common in the North, and moderates did not to impose stricter laws on the south that those in the North.

Carpetbagger & Scalawags

During radical reconstruction, the Republican Party was a mixture of people who had little in common but a desire to prosper in the postwar south. This bloc of voters included freedmen and two other groups.

Northern Republicans who moved to postwar became known as carpetbaggers. The southerners gave them this insulting nickname; it referred to a cheap suitcase made from carpet scraps. The Name implied that these southerners stuffed their clothes into a carpetbag and rushed into a profit from southern misery.

In the postwar south, to be white and southerner and a Republican was to be seen as traitors. Southerners had another name form the unflattering name for white southern Republicans as well; Scalawag, originally a word in Scottish which meant scrawny cattle. Some of the scalawags were Whigs who had opposed succession.


Reconstruction in Action

1

The war has just ended and it is time for the civilians to reconstruct their nation, but the war has left much misery behind it. It had destroyed much of the transportation and accumulated a total of 9,000 miles of railroad. It had devoured farm lands and farm building and machinery. Animals that were used in the farm and much of the livestock, bridges and canals all were gone. the value of the southern farm properties had declined of 70 precent.

The civil war has just destroyed many lives. Men, husbands and brothers all died leaving behind their family; their wives and their children. The north has suffered a loss of over 364,000 people and more than 38,000 African American while the south lost 260,000 soldiers and only one fifth of them were white men. The people who have participated to the war are scarred for eternity but we are trying to reconstruct our nation.

After the civil war the African Americans in the south were now free. Over 4 million freed slaves are starting their new life in a poor region with slow economic activities. As slaves they have received inadequate food and shelter but now after a lifetime of forced labor and unreasoned suffering many are homeless, famished and jobless. Some of them though have chosen to continue on working on the plantation of their previous masters, others sought jobs on the West and the cities and on the North as well.

With out our president, Abraham Lincoln who was savagely assassinated we the nation of the United states are having a little of difficulty reconstructing our country and though with our previous Vice President and now President of the Untied States, Andrew Johnson who now all the hopes and future of reconstruction are in his hand.

Andrew Johnson was born in North Carolina. After Lincoln's death it was for the Vice president to take in charge of the nation and of the politics of it.

Before the start of his presidential state Johnson had already pursuit a plan for our nation's construction. It was much similar to the one done by our respected president Lincoln's plan in 1863.

This plan proposed a whole new start of the nation. It offered pardon to southerners who swore allegiance to the Union and the state could then hold elections and rejoin the Union.

The plan for the reconstruction of our nation now is to gather the southerners and the northerners in to one same political unit. The plan to reconstruct our nation is to join the Union.


The Effects of War

0

The war has many effects on the people or nation could negative and positive. In the civil war of 1861 -1865 the war was negative and positive at the same time. It was negative because lots of people died in the massacre and they were from the same nation. It was positive in making this new nation a stronger and more united than it ever has. The effects of war are also different for people. There are people that gain something from the war and that makes them happy. Military industries for example, the war is something good for them because they sell their products (weapons, guns...) to the army. It is a build up of economy. For other people it is only the ruin of their lives.


Ken Burnʼs Civil War

1
The movie of Ken Burn's traced the course of the U.S. civil war in 1861 -1865. It was from the abolitionist to the death of the greatest president the United States has ever had, Abraham Lincoln. It also had a bit of the beginning reconstructions. The episode we've watched in class examines the major causes of the American civil war and the leading people on both sides.
Slavery is looked at and it was part of the cause of war but not the actual cause. The abolitionist John Brown's attack on a southern armory at Harper's Ferry speeded things up?
The main cause of the war was the key issue of the states rights and whether or not they could vote to leave the American Union. The first major battle at Manassas was a mortifying defeat for the much stronger Northerners.